THOUGHT LEADERSHIP

‘Dams for People, Water, Environment and Development’ – some reflections from ICOLD 2024

Entura’s Amanda Ashworth (Managing Director) and Richard Herweynen (Technical Director, Water) recently attended the International Commission on Large Dams (ICOLD) 2024 Annual Meeting and International Symposium, held in New Delhi. Amanda presented on building dam safety capability, skills and competencies, while Richard presented on Hydro Tasmania’s risk-based, systems approach to dam safety management, and the importance of pumped hydro in Australia’s energy transition. 

Here they share some reflections on ICOLD 2024 …

Richard Herweynen – on the value of storage, ‘right dams’, and stewardship

At ICOLD 2024 we were reminded again that water storages will be critical for the world’s ability to deal with climate change and meet the growing global population’s needs for food and water. We can expect greater climate variability and therefore more variability in river flows, which means that more storage will be needed to ensure a high level of reliability of water supply. Without more water storages to buffer climate impacts, heavily water-dependent sectors like agriculture will be impacted.

To slow the rate of climate change, we must decarbonise our economies – but without significant energy storage, it will be difficult to transition from thermal power to variable renewable energy (wind and solar). Pablo Valverde, representing the International Hydropower Association (IHA), said at the conference that ‘storage is the hidden crisis within the crisis’. There was a lot of discussion at ICOLD 2024 about pumped hydro energy storage as a promising part of the solution. It is also important, however, to remember that conventional hydropower, with significant water storage, can be repurposed operationally to provide a firming role too. Water storage is the biggest ‘battery’ of the world and will be a critical element in the energy transition.

With the title of the ICOLD Symposium being ‘Dams for People, Water, Environment and Development’, I reflected again on the need for ‘right dams’ rather than ‘no dams’. ‘Right dams’ are those that achieve a balance among people, water, environment and development. In the opening address, we were reminded of the links between ‘ecology’ and ‘economy’ – which are not only connected by their linguistic roots but also by the dependence of any successful economy on the natural environment. It is our ethical responsibility to manage the environment with care.

When planning and designing water storages, we must recognise that a river provides ecological services and that affected people should be engaged and involved in achieving the right balance. If appropriate project sites are selected and designs strive to mitigate impacts, it is possible for a dam project’s positive contribution to be greater than its environmental impact, as was showcased in number of projects presented at the ICOLD gathering. Finding the balance is our challenge as dam engineers.

The president of ICOLD, Michel Lino, reminded delegates that the safety of dams has always been ICOLD’s focus, and that there is more to be done to improve dam safety around the world. At one session, Piotr Sliwinski discussed the Topola Dam in Poland, which failed during recent floods due to overtopping of the emergency spillway. Sharing and learning together from such experiences is an important benefit of participating in the ICOLD community.

Alejandro Pujol from Argentina, who chaired one of the ‘Dam Safety Management and Engineering’ sessions, reflected that in ICOLD’s early years the focus was on better ways to design and construct new dams, but the spotlight has now shifted to the long-term health of existing dams. It is critical that dams remain safe throughout the challenges that nature delivers, from floods to earthquakes. In reality, dams usually continue to operate long beyond their 80–100 year design life if they are structurally safe, as evidenced in the examples of long-lived dams presented by Martin Wieland from Switzerland. He suggested that the lifespan of well-designed, well-constructed, well-maintained and well-operated dams can even exceed 200 years. As dam engineers, no matter the part we play in the life of a dam, we have a responsibility to do it well.

From my conversations with a number of dam engineers representing the ICOLD Young Professional Forum (YPF), and seeing the progress of this body within the ICOLD community, I believe that the dam industry is in good hands – although, of course, there is always more to be done. I was pleased to see an Australian, Brandon Pearce, voted onto the ICOLD YPF Board.

Another YPF member, Sam Tudor from the UK, reminded us in his address of the importance of knowledge transfer, the moral obligation we all have especially to the downstream communities of our dams, and our stewardship role. He was referencing his experience of looking after dams that are more than 120 years old – all built long before he was born. Many of our colleagues across Entura and Hydro Tasmania feel this same sense of responsibility and pride when we work on Hydro Tasmania’s assets, which were built over more than a century and have been fundamental to shaping our state’s economy and delivering the quality of life we now enjoy. It is up to all of us to carry the positive legacy of these assets forward with care and custodianship, for the benefit of future generations.

Amanda Ashworth – on costs and benefits, dam safety, and an inclusive workforce

Like Richard, I found much food for thought at ICOLD 2024. For me, it reinforced the need to accelerate hydropower globally, particularly in places where the total resource is as yet underdeveloped. To do so, we will need regulatory frameworks that support success – such as by monetising storage and recognising it as an official use – and administrative reforms that ease the challenges of achieving planning approvals, grid connection agreements and financing for long-duration storage. We must encourage research and development to move our sector forward: from multi-energy hybrids to advanced construction materials and innovations to improve rehabilitation.

In particular, I’ve been reflecting on how our sector could extend our thinking and discourse about the impacts and benefits equation beyond the broad answer that dams are good for the net zero transition. How can we enact and communicate the many other potential local environmental and social benefits and long-term value from dams?

Much of the world’s existing critical infrastructure came at a significant financial expense as well as social and environmental costs – so it is our obligation to pay back that investment by maximising every dam’s effective life. When we invest in extending the lifespan of dam infrastructure through effective asset management and maintenance, and when we maximise generation or the value of storage in the market, we increase the ‘return on investment’ against the financial, social and environmental impacts incurred in the past.

Of course, the global dams community must continue to prioritise dam safety and work towards a ‘safety culture’. I was pleased to hear Debashree Mukherjee, Secretary of the Ministry of Jal Shakti, celebrate the progress on finalising regulations across states to enact India’s Federal Dam Safety Act and establishing two centres of excellence to lift capacity across the nation. Dam safety depends on well-trained people with the right skills and competencies to comply with evolving standards, apply new technologies, and respond effectively to changing operational circumstances and demands. 

I also enjoyed hearing from ICOLD’s gender and diversity committee on its progress, including updates from around 14 nations on their efforts to build a more inclusive renewable energy and dams workforce. This is front of mind for us, as we step up Entura’s own focus and actions on gender equity throughout our business this year.

The challenges facing our dams community – and our planet – are enormous, but there is certainly much to be excited about, and we look forward to continuing these important conversations over the next year.

From Richard, Amanda and Entura’s team, many thanks to the Indian National Committee on Large Dams (INCOLD) for organising and hosting this year’s ICOLD event, supporting our sector to build international professional networks, and facilitating the sharing of experiences and knowledge across the globe – all of which are so important for growing the ‘ICOLD family’ and supporting a safer, more resilient and more sustainable water and energy future.

October 10, 2024